Skip to main content

The Doctor and the Saint by Arundhati Roy

Image
By on
The Doctor and the Saint is a nonfiction essay, a theoretical debate between two towering figures in Indian history: B.R. Ambedkar and M.K. Gandhi. The "doctor" refers to Ambedkar, jurist, economist, and the chief architect of India’s Constitution, while the "saint" is Gandhi, the internationally revered leader of India’s independence movement.

Roy challenges the sanitized image of Gandhi often taught in mainstream narratives, especially regarding his views and actions on caste. She contrasts this with Ambedkar’s radical anti-caste politics, his lived experience as a Dalit, and his demand for dignity and structural change. The book not only examines their ideological rift but also asks hard questions about how we remember history, who gets to tell it, and what justice really looks like.

In the book, Arundhati Roy writes:

For a writer to have to use terms like ‘Untouchable,’ ‘Scheduled Caste,’ ‘Backward Class,’ and ‘Other Backward Classes’ to describe fellow human beings is like living in a chamber of horrors.

That line lands hard.
And no, it’s not dramatic. It’s just the truth.

It hits especially hard when you come from

  •  a family that has to spend money to apply for an OBC certificate so they can apply for a job or take an exam. And even then, they rarely get selected. And even if they do, there’s no money to pay the bribes “required” to access those opportunities. Some of us aren’t willing to play that game.
  •  a community made up of people constantly identified by labels—SC, ST, OBC.
  •  a place that’s been burning in violence for over two years, and still not a single word from the Prime Minister. No visit. Not even acknowledgment. (Did he?)
  •  a state that’s now underwater, literally flooded—and yet, you can’t help but wonder if anyone in power really notices or cares.

Roy names what so many try to silence. And if you’ve lived even a piece of this reality, you know it’s not an overstatement. It’s survival.

Yeah, that and anyway, I think this will be an interesting read for 

  • Those interested in Indian history, social justice, or decolonial thinking.
  • Readers who want to understand caste beyond surface-level discussions.
  • Anyone ready to rethink what they were taught about Gandhi.
🤍🤍🤍

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Upstream: Selected Essays by Mary Oliver

By on
It was a joy reading Upstream by Mary Oliver. H ere are a few quotes and phrases from the book that I want to keep remembering. "you must not, ever, give anyone else the responsibility for your life" "I quickly found for myself two such blessings- the natural world, and the world of writing: literature. These were the gates through which I vanished from a difficult place." "Reading, then writing, then desiring to write well, shaped in me that most joyful of circumstances- a passion for work." "..having chosen to claim my life, I have made for myself, out of work and love, a handsome life" "And that I did not give to anyone the responsibility for my life. It is mine. I made it. And can do what I want to with it. Live it. Give it back, someday, without bitterness, to the wild and weedy dunes." "Creative work needs solitude. It needs concentration, without interruptions. It needs the whole sky to fly in, and no eye watching until it c...
Post a Comment
Read more

November 2025 Reads—Elena Ferrante and Vandana Shiva

By on
End of the month today, here are the books I read. 1. My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferrante 2. The Story of a New Name by Elena Ferrante 3. Those Who Leave and Those Who Stay by Elena Ferrante 4. The Story of the Lost Child by Elena Ferrante 5. Oneness vs. the 1% by Vandana Shiva, Kartikey Shiva Yes, I read the Neapolitan novels, all four books by Elena Ferrante. Lina and Elena gave me company, the whole month, my head was full of what Lina did, what Elena said, etc, etc.  1. My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferrante "I feel no nostalgia for our childhood: it was full of violence." The first novel follows the intense, complicated friendship between Elena Greco and Lila Cerullo as they grow up in a poor neighbourhood in postwar Naples. Amid violence, poverty, and rigid social expectations, the girls push each other intellectually and emotionally, shaping one another’s ambitions even as their paths begin to diverge. The novel explores how identity is formed through rivalry, admirat...
Post a Comment
Read more

Wake up, Wake up, Children of the Land!—Poem by Tombi

By on
Wake up, wake up, Children of the Land! You hear and hear, yet turn a deaf ear. You see and see, yet close your eyes. You know, you know, but pretend not to know. Wake up, wake up, Children of the Land! The world has seen the light of science. Has your time not come? Are you still chasing ghosts of old history? Have you forgotten? Do you not remember? Who are you? Where do you come from? To which place do you belong? Who are you to ignore the past that shaped you? Is your behaviour still human nature? Wake up, wake up, Children of the Land! There will be rain. There will be flood. Does fear still dwell in your heart? A tiger does not spare a deer. Have you forgotten? Do you not wish to write a new history? Do you not wish to be brave? Be wary, even as you sleep, Your own blood has turned cold. Like seeks like, and power pairs with power. That history, written by the mighty, Do you wish to let it rule again? Do you not wish to end it? Do you not wish to become Our fath...
Post a Comment
Read more